Watch the full NBC News/National Journal/Tampa Bay Times GOP presidential debate as Newt Gingrich and Mitt Romney set a combative ahead of Florida's Jan. 31 primary.
Updated 10:56 p.m. ET
The long-awaited showdown between Newt Gingrich and Mitt Romney erupted into a slugfest at a Republican presidential debate in Florida, setting a combative tone in the campaign ahead of the state's Jan. 31 primary.
The former House speaker and the former Massachusetts governor began sniping early at Monday evening's NBC News/National Journal/Tampa Bay Times debate; they carried on through much of the debate before finding more conciliatory turf when answering questions specific to the state of Florida.
Still, the gathering delivered what had been expected: Romney taking a new, aggressive tack against Gingrich, and Gingrich finding himself in the frontrunner's spotlight after having scored a decisive victory in last weekend's South Carolina primary.
The sharpest exchange over the evening came over Gingrich's work on behalf of troubled mortgage giant Freddie Mac. Romney had assailed that work, which earned Gingrich's consulting firm a lucrative contract, on the campaign trail, and repeated it tonight.
"The fact is I offered strategic advice, largely based on my knowledge of history, including the history of Washington," Gingrich said of his work. (His campaign released a copy of his contract with Freddie Mac this evening at the behest of the Romney campaign.)
At Monday's Republican presidential debate in Florida, the showdown between former Massachusetts Governor Mitt Romney and former House Speaker Newt Gingrich erupted into a verbal slugfest. NBC's Peter Alexander reports.
Romney insisted that Gingrich's advocacy work on behalf of Freddie Mac — as well as the ex-speaker's push for a prescription drug benefit in Medicare during a legislative battle in 2003 — represented nothing more than lobbying by another name.
"If you're getting paid by health companies … and you then meet with Republican congressmen and encourage them to support that legislation, you can call it whatever you'd like. I call it influence-peddling," Romney said. "It is not right. It is not right. You have a conflict."
The sparring between Romney and Gingrich was reflective of the uncertainty injected into the primary campaign by Gingrich's victory in South Carolina. None of the four candidates onstage tonight in Tampa has won more than a single nominating contest, and the campaign now threatens to extend into Super Tuesday and beyond.
Romney had sent every signal between Saturday night and Monday evening's debate that he planned to take a more aggressive tack against Gingrich as part of an effort to halt the former speaker's momentum in Florida, which isn't just a key primary state, but a pivotal swing state in the general election, as well.
'Historic losses'
Romney launched into the criticism in his very first answer, assailing Gingrich as an unreliable conservative who could embarrass the GOP.
Former speaker on the defensive over his role as a paid adviser for Freddie Mac, insurance companies.
"The speaker was given an opportunity to be the leader of our party in 1994. And at the end of four years, he had to resign in disgrace," Romney said.
"Don't forget at the end of the speaker's term as speaker, his approval rating was down to 18 percent. We suffered historic losses after his four years in office," Romney added.
For his part, Gingrich opened on a more optimistic note and appeared reluctant at first to engage Romney's attacks.
"I'm not going to spend the evening trying to chase Gov. Romney's misinformation," Gingrich said, explaining his campaign would provide rejoinders on its website tomorrow morning. "He just said four things that were false. I don't want to waste any time on them."
But any hopes for a high-brow affair quickly disappeared when Gingrich sharply disputed Romney's account of his speakership: "He may have made a good financier. He's a terrible historian."
It was the kind of red-hot fight most political observers had expected after the GOP presidential primary was thrown into upheaval by the former House speaker's victory in this past weekend's in South Carolina.
The two GOP front-runners battle over their past in a pivotal NBC News debate.
The debate was one of the fiercest battles of the Republican campaign, presaged by a day of sniping on the campaign trail that saw the Romney and Gingrich trade rhetorical blows in a preview of the new phase of the GOP campaign.
The Romney campaign is hoping Florida proves to be a firewall against Gingrich's surge. They've spent millions on advertising in the state, and Romney has enjoyed an early advantage in the polls — one his campaign hopes transfers to the over 225,000 early and absentee ballots that have been cast.
But the voting is limited to registered Republicans only, meaning the electorate might be composed of the more conservative voters that fueled Gingrich's win in South Carolina. Gingrich is hoping that twin victories in South Carolina and Florida would decimate the aura of inevitability Romney built around his campaign.
Texas Rep. Ron Paul has elected against participating in Florida with much vigor. He spent most of the debate voicing his usual message, decrying government spending and U.S. involvement in foreign conflicts.
NBC's Andrea Mitchell, David Gregory and Chuck Todd provide analysis following tonight's GOP debate.
Former Pennsylvania Sen. Rick Santorum, the winner of the Iowa caucus by the slimmest of margins, put himself forward at the debate as the only true conservative. He went on the attack against Gingrich and Romney by saying there is little different between them and President Obama.
"They rejected conservatism when it was hard to stand. It's going to be hard to stand whoever this president is going to be elected," Santorum said, echoing that same line of attack at the end of the debate. "There is no difference between President Obama and these two gentlemen. And that's why this election in Florida is so critical, that we have someone that actually can create a contrast between the president and the conservative point of view."
Republican presidential hopeful Mitt Romney released his tax returns, which reveal he paid a 14 percent rate on nearly $22 million in income for 2010. NBC's Chuck Todd talks to TODAY's Matt Lauer about how this release might impact the race.
Romney, on the attack for much of the night, stumbled on a question regarding how he would handle illegal immigrants residing in the United States.
"Well, the answer is self-deportation, which is people decide they can do better by going home because they can't find work here because they don't have legal documentation to allow them to work here," Romney said, raising eyebrows if nothing else than for the opacity of the concept. "And so we're not going to round people up."


Why is Ron Paul ignored. He is the only one up there who is like most Americans. Sick of rich lawyers running our country.
Newt is the father of the scorched earth politics that we suffer through today. The all out single minded assault on all things Clinton. Only to resign in disgrace. Does the cat really change their stripes ? From his style and tone obviously nothing changed. For sure his candidacy and election would help a few. But America ? It is hard to see how America and Americans would benefit.
For Romney I am sure that the task is unpleasant, but necessary.
Newt, Clinton and Gore were buddies. Make no mistake about it. They were and are Third Way disciples.
All things Clinton? The policies that the republicans offered Clinton is what balanced the budget and help the tremendous growth during that time. Clinton would never have signed on to welfare reform, spending cuts etc. Fortunately, the GOP stood their ground and we ended up with good times.
They never balanced the budget. It was hocus pocus.
Spending from 1995-2000 increased 19.33%, while tax revenues over that same period increased 50%.
*all figures in billions, rounded
(year) (receipts) (outlays) (deficit)
1995 1350 1500 -164
1996 1450 1560 -107
1997 1580 1600 -22
1998 1720 1650 +69
1999 1830 1700 +125
2000 2025 1790 +236
taxpolicycenter.org/taxfacts/displayafact.cfm?Docid=200
The "surplus" or “balanced budget” as Newt likes to call it, was mostly created by an accounting gimmick, declaring certain things to be off budget, particularly Social Security. He never balanced a single thing.(Try declaring your mortgage “off budget” and see how long you remain a homeowner!)
Here is the US government debt by year since 1982. It increases every year so there couldn't have been a balanced budget!
07/22/2009 11,634,723,000,000.00
09/30/2008 10,024,724,896,912.49
09/30/20079,007,653,372,262.48
09/30/20068,506,973,899,215.23
09/30/20057,932,709,661,723.50
09/30/20047,379,052,696,330.32
09/30/20036,783,231,062,743.62
09/30/20026,228,235,965,597.16
09/30/20015,807,463,412,200.06
09/30/20005,674,178,209,886.86
09/30/19995,656,270,901,615.43
09/30/19985,526,193,008,897.62
09/30/19975,413,146,011,397.34
09/30/19965,224,810,939,135.73
09/29/19954,973,982,900,709.39
09/30/19944,692,749,910,013.32
09/30/19934,411,488,883,139.38
09/30/19924,064,620,655,521.66
09/30/19913,665,303,351,697.03
09/28/19903,233,313,451,777.25
09/29/19892,857,430,960,187.32
09/30/19882,602,337,712,041.16
09/30/19872,350,276,890,953.00
09/30/19862,125,302,616,658.42
09/30/19851,823,103,000,000.00
09/30/19841,572,266,000,000.00
09/30/19831,377,210,000,000.00
09/30/19821,142,034,000,000.00
While we are discussing truth and facts....you do realize that to prevent inflation from soaring and being yet another problem for the present administration, food and fuel have been removed from the cost of living index, which is probably two of the largest expenditures for most families-especially now that housing is not because so many families are either in default, involved in a government backed bailout program, receiving housing assistance.....well, if we don't have to factor in the cost of food, a place to live, and transportation to get us to and from work, I guess that there simply isn't inflation. Nice how that works, isn't it.
The balanced budgets and surpluses did not occur until after Gingrich left office.
The main reason for the very temporary balanced budgets, and nice little surpluses, was the effects of the greed of the irrational dangerous exuberance of the corporate fraud of the dot.com (Enron) bubble of the late 90's.
Once that collapsed in March 2000, all was toast - and massive deficits were inevitable in short order.
NBC stacked the audience. It will get the lowest ratings of the debates to date
What is wrong with this debate? it's not a debate. The questions are "news gossip". Really poorly run! They turned this into the "Republican Reality Show" to give fodder to their newcasters.
Like Obama is any better. Deer in the head lights. I can't wait until he starts imprisoning Americans citizens for disagreeing with him...sorry, I meant for being a terrorist.
Central government planning and control = loss of freedom
It amazes me that those on the Left want to be free, think they are free, hate the elitists but the very system of government they advocate for is one built on elitism and privilege!
You are just a useful idiot in the eyes of the Left. The only way you get in with that crowd is if you're allowed in. Sounds exactly like the Right too come to think about it.
Please don't vote for the same blow hards again. Haven't we done enough of that in our history?
digging up bones..has the whole god darn republican party gone crazy
Very sad excuse for a moderator. Focus on the people needing jobs. Instead Brian is creating clips for the Obama campaign.
the republicans have a mouth dont they..whats keeping them from saying what they will do
the tea Party always said they wanted someone new....hahahahah
Not interesting, it is a waste of time. Finally getting to a topic.
NBC we know you are trying to brainwash the American people into choosing between Mitt and Newt. We are not gonna fall for it. Ron Paul has more supporters than those 2 combined and you know it. That's why you are not allowing Paul to speak that much. America is waking up. Guess you better get the FEMA camps ready bc there are a lot of Ron Paul people out here.
no you dont need help..you already there
Ron Paul or Santorum. Santorum has a better chance of getting elected. Unlike Newt, he doesn't have as much baggage. Unlike Newt and Romney, he is a conservative.
I must admit to finding Santorum a very unique person in the world of politics-somebody striving not to be involved in muck raking and mud slinging, somebody actually trying to stay on topic and discuss issues and possible solutions, and guess what, I really don't care if he likes sweater vests, doesn't have a stylist and doesn't look all that GQ.
I'm watching the debate now, but Brian Williams is such a stuffed-shirt windbag. I think he wants to hear himself talk more than the candidates!
they have a mouth dont they
Jackass poser gettin his comeuppance shortly as SCOTUS scuttles the IM. Never mind them Paul Bearers, they just a cult of fanatics. Guard the WH doors come November: O goin down in a landslide, the First Goldigress gonna pack suitcases fulla WH silver on her way out.
Romney practically telling Grinch he broke the law (influence peddaling) ... Grinch trying to retaliate and change the subject about Bain creating nothing more than $8 an hour jobs to enrich Romney for hudreds of millions ..
Trippy, is that they're both right ... LOL.
These guys are jokes! Obama/Biden 2012!
Newt has this attitude that he is above the others. Wait until more of his baggage comes out, and there is plenty more to come. He will implode.
I'm a democrat and Obama supporter, but am also interested in GOP politics. I'm glad to see Romney finally take it to Gingrich. Even the possibility of that guy running this country is scary. Newt is running for Emperor, not president.
the whole party is the anti-Christ party..if anyone of these fools get in ..they all will have a job.in the white house
the liberals help the tea party pick there guys..hahahaha
Ron Paul is a joke!
and crazy
Has Newt heard of the Bay of Pigs?
Yeah I just saw that ... Cuban Spring ?
just think about it folks..if they get elected..soon we will all be a brothers from another mother.we can rape there mothers and have a child.together..we will all be related
They mentioned CRA's and blamed them for the housing crisis - default under these loans were actually lower than for the regular private mainstream bank loans.
Now Newt wants to overthrow Cuba along with Iran????????
he like cubans and mexicans just on election day..oh and blacks.
Brian Williams take that ear piece out of your ear and quit listening to that person on the other end telling you not to go to Ron Paul.
are you a physic or psycho
Are you a kool-aid drinker or do you just have your head in the sand? btw I think you meant psychic.
reading your post im am glad i have my head in the sand
Keep watching tv. Everything is under control. Trust me.
Signed, The U.S. Government
calm down stay away from the light
Vietnam is much better when we stopped war and opened trade.